Over the last twenty-five years, ESG (Environmental, Social & Governance) has emerged from the backwaters of the investment management process to become central to the management of financial assets. What started as ethical investing for a few charitable trusts and endowments wanting to avoid sectors like defence, tobacco and alcohol in the 1990s has evolved into a central pillar of mainstream capital allocation. More recently, however, the rise of ESG has encountered some headwinds.
In our April 2022 update, we suggested that ESG might become a casualty of the war in Ukraine and that the accepted ESG framework might require a refresh. While ESG was under pressure before the February 24th Russian invasion, Putin’s devastating actions have undoubtedly intensified this pressure.
In recent weeks there have been some noticeable ripples on the usually calm and consensual surface of ESG investing. Probably the most high profile event was the police raid on the offices of DWS in Frankfurt amid allegations of greenwashing and the subsequent resignation of its CEO. Additionally, the Head of Sustainable Investing at HSBC Asset Management was suspended for suggesting that we might have collectively overestimated the cost of climate change. And in the US, S&P’s decision to exclude the EV pioneer from its ESG Index while retaining Exxon prompted Elon Musk to tweet that ESG was a sham.
Beneath these events are some hard truths that face the accepted wisdom of ESG. The hardest of these truths are in the energy transition debate. Before February 24th, the West and Europe, in particular, did not consider Russia’s poor human rights record as sufficient reason not to buy its energy.
Today Europe is heading towards a previously unthinkable future without Russian oil and gas. The rush to source energy that is not Russian has meant that we are building bridges with some unsavoury oil-producing countries, such as Saudi Arabia and Venezuela. Germany is building facilities to import LNG; the UK is incentivising new investment in the North Sea, and everyone is re-evaluating their nuclear energy options.
The new priority of energy security has allowed people to speak up in defence of what was previously assumed to be ‘the indefensible’, albeit it wasn’t career-enhancing for Stuart Kirk of HSBC. If you look up who owns the largest oil reserves in the world, it is often surprising to see Canada, a non-OPEC+ member, in the top three. However, most of Canada’s oil is in the form of its heavy tar sand deposits, which are only economic to extract when the oil price is well above $100, along with some nasty environmental considerations.
Unsurprisingly the people of Alberta Province in Canada are becoming vocal. Provincial premier Jason Kenny said, “hostility is beginning to soften as leaders are mugged by reality. We cannot allow some of the world’s worst regimes to dominate global energy markets. We can supply the US with oil, and there will be no need to deploy the US Navy on the Great Lakes.” Thus he reinforces the point that the Canadians are the ‘nice’ Americans. The critical question is whether the decision to cancel the KXL pipeline connecting Albertan oil to the US Gulf Coast can be reversed. A downward sloping forward curve for oil and an ESG framework that has substantially increased the cost of capital for such projects are limiting factors. (Indeed, the same factors restrict the output of the shale deposits from the Permian Basin in Texas and Oklahoma).
While the markets remain concerned about interest rates and inflation, the dominant theme in equity markets so far in 2022 has been energy. The defining factor of investment performance year to date has been energy exposure. With crude oil, natural gas and thermal coal prices all substantially higher, the share of the market cap for the energy sector has increased. However, valuations do not currently indicate this change will be permanent. Despite their stellar share price performance, oil company valuations remain historically low. They do not suggest a long-term future of sharply higher energy prices.
What is the market telling us? Why is the market not discounting higher energy prices and a better future for oil companies? There are two factors at play here. First is that through its ESG lens, oil exploration and development remain un-investible despite the apparent low valuations. Second, the market is discounting significantly lower oil prices in the foreseeable future. Indeed, with most commentators forecasting an economic slowdown and others a recession, like Musk’s ‘super bad feeling’ and Jamie Dimon’s ‘hurricane’ warning, this is not good news for oil prices.
In the 1970s, when OPEC was exerting its control over the oil supply to Western markets, it took us a decade to find alternative supplies from places like Alaska and the North Sea. The West responded by lowering its demand for OPEC oil via two painful recessions, substituting gas-guzzling cars for smaller Japanese imports, rationing power and imposing speed limits on motorways. This time our journey will involve less demand for Russian oil and gas. However, alternative energy sources are more obvious even if they are bridging fuels to get us to a fully renewable future. Locally sourced bridging fuel projects can give investors strong returns in the current climate. However, the ESG lens might need an adjustment to bring them to fruition.
Dowgate Wealth was formed with the belief that sustainable compound returns are best generated from bespoke investment portfolios. We also believe that no client is the same and we must deliver high levels of personalised and on time service. This is contrary to the overly centralised asset allocation approach which has enamoured the asset management industry over recent years. In a world which continues to change, our philosophy allows us to remain flexible to continuously meet our clients’ needs.
You are attempting to enter a part of the website containing materials which may be restricted under the securities laws of certain jurisdictions.
Please read this notice carefully – it applies to all persons who view this webpage. The disclaimer set out below may be altered or updated from time to time. You should read it in full each time you visit the site.
The materials you are seeking to access are made available in good faith and for information purposes only and are subject to the terms and conditions set out below. Any person seeking to access this webpage represents and warrants to the Company that they are doing so for information purposes only. Further, it does not constitute a recommendation by the Company or any associated company or any other person to subscribe for or buy securities in the Company. The information on this website is general in nature and does not in any way constitute investment, tax, legal or other advice. To allow you to view information about the Company, you must read this notice and then click “I AGREE”. If you are unable to agree, you should click “I DISAGREE” and you will not be able to view information about the Company.
Nothing on, or which can be downloaded from, this webpage constitutes an offer for sale or subscription or any solicitation for any offer to buy or subscribe for any securities in any jurisdiction. Any such purchase or subscription must be made only on the basis of the information contained in an admission document relating to the Company in its final form (the “Admission Document “). Any decision made to purchase or subscribe for any securities should be made solely and only on the basis of the information provided in the Admission Document.
The materials are only addressed to and directed at persons in the United Kingdom that are “qualified investors” within the meaning of the UK version of the EU Prospectus Regulation which forms part of UK domestic law pursuant to the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 and are persons: (a) who have professional experience in matters relating to investments falling within Article 19(5) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Financial Promotion) Order 2005 (the “Order”) (investment professionals); (b) who fall within Article 49(2)(a) to (d) of the Order (high net worth companies, unincorporated associations etc.); or (c) to whom it may otherwise be lawfully distributed (all such persons in (a), (b) and (c) together being referred to as “Relevant Persons”). Any investment or investment activity to which these materials relate is available only to Relevant Persons, and will only be engaged with such persons.
Overseas jurisdictions
Viewing the materials you are seeking to access may be restricted under securities laws in certain jurisdictions. In other jurisdictions, only certain categories of person may be allowed to view the materials. All persons who wish to view this webpage must first satisfy themselves that they are not subject to any local requirements which prohibit or restrict them from doing so and should inform themselves about, and observe, any applicable legal or regulatory requirements applicable in their jurisdiction.
These materials are not directed at persons located or resident in the United States, Canada, Japan, Australia, the Republic of South Africa, New Zealand, any member state of the European Economic Area or in any other jurisdiction outside of the United Kingdom, Guernsey and Jersey (each a “Restricted Jurisdiction”).
The materials do not constitute an offer to issue or sell, or the solicitation of an offer to subscribe for or buy, any securities to any person in any jurisdiction to whom it is unlawful to make such offer or solicitation in such jurisdiction. Without limiting the generality of the foregoing, these materials do not constitute an offer of securities to any person with a registered address, or who is resident in, the United States, or who is otherwise a “US Person” as defined in Regulation S under the United States Securities Act of 1933 (as amended) (the “US Securities Act“). There will be no public offer of securities in the United States. Outside of the United States, the securities are being offered in reliance on Regulation S promulgated under the US Securities Act. These materials may not be distributed directly or indirectly to any persons with addresses in the United States or any of its territories or possessions unless in accordance with applicable law.
If you are not permitted to view materials on this website or are in any doubt as to whether you are permitted to view these materials, please exit this webpage. You should not mail, forward, release, distribute, publish, send or show the information or documents contained on this webpage, in whole or in part, directly or indirectly, to any person. In particular, you should not mail, forward, release, distribute, publish or send the information or documents contained therein, in whole or in part, directly or indirectly, to a Restricted Jurisdiction or any other jurisdiction where it would be unlawful to do so. Persons receiving such documents (including custodians, nominees and trustees) must not release, distribute, publish or send them in, into or from a Restricted Jurisdiction.
Forward looking statements
This webpage and the information contained herein contains certain forward looking statements. These statements relate to, among other things, analyses and other information that are based on forecasts of future results and estimates of amounts not yet determinable. These statements also relate to the Company’s future prospectus, development and business strategies. These forward looking statements are identified by the use of terms and phrases such as “anticipate”, “believe”, “could”, “estimate”, “expect”, “intend”, “may”, “plan”, “predict”, “project, “will” or the negative of those variations, or comparable expressions, including references to assumptions. These statements, including statements containing projections of the Company’s future results, operating profits and earnings, are based on current expectations and subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from those expressed or implied by those statements. By their nature, forward looking statements involve risk and uncertainty and the factors described in the context of such forward looking statements could cause actual results and developments to differ materially from those expressed in or implied by such forward looking statements.
Should one or more of these risks or uncertainties materialise, or should underlying assumptions prove incorrect, actual results may vary materially from those described in this webpage and the information contained herein. Except as required by applicable law or regulation, neither the Company, nor its advisers nor any of their respective agents, assumes or undertakes any obligation to update or correct the information contained in this webpage and the information contained herein.
None of the Company, Cavendish Capital Markets Limited (“Cavendish“), Dowgate Capital Limited (“Dowgate Capital“) or any other person has, or accepts: (i) any responsibility or duty to update any information, document or announcement contained on this website and the Company reserves the right to add to, remove or amend any information available on this website at any time; or (ii) any responsibility in respect of any information contained on any other website which may be linked to or from this website.
Cavendish, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA“) in the United Kingdom, is acting exclusively for the Company and no one else in connection with the matters referred to on this website and will not be acting for any other person or otherwise responsible to any person other than the Company for providing the protections afforded to clients of Cavendish or for advising any other person in relation to any matters referred to on this website. Apart from the responsibilities and liabilities, if any, which may be imposed on Cavendish by the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, as amended (“FSMA“), or the regulatory regime established thereunder, Cavendish accepts no responsibility whatsoever for the contents of this website or for any statement made or purported to be made by it, or on its behalf, in connection with the Company. Cavendish, its subsidiaries, branches and affiliates accordingly disclaim all and any liability whether arising in tort, contract or otherwise (save as referred to above) which it might otherwise have in respect of such material or any such statement.
Dowgate Capital, which is authorised and regulated by the FCA in the United Kingdom, is acting exclusively for the Company and no one else in connection with the matters referred to on this website and will not be acting for any other person or otherwise responsible to any person other than the Company for providing the protections afforded to clients of Dowgate Capital or for advising any other person in relation to any matters referred to on this website. Apart from the responsibilities and liabilities, if any, which may be imposed on Dowgate Capital by the FSMA, or the regulatory regime established thereunder, Dowgate Capital accepts no responsibility whatsoever for the contents of this website or for any statement made or purported to be made by it, or on its behalf, in connection with the Company. Dowgate Capital, its subsidiaries, branches and affiliates accordingly disclaim all and any liability whether arising in tort, contract or otherwise (save as referred to above) which it might otherwise have in respect of such material or any such statement.
Confirmation of understanding and acceptance
By clicking ‘I agree’ below, you represent, warrant and agree that:
YOU ARE NOT ACCESSING THIS WEBSITE FROM WITHIN THE UNITED STATES OR FROM ANY OTHER RESTRICTED JURISDICTION; AND
YOU ARE NOT A U.S. PERSON (AS DEFINED IN REGULATION S UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT) OR OTHERWISE RESIDENT IN THE UNITED STATES OR ANY OTHER RESTRICTED JURISDICTION; AND
YOU ARE NOT INVESTING OR OTHERWISE ACTING FOR THE ACCOUNT OR BENEFIT OF A US PERSON OR A RESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OR ANY OTHER RESTRICTED JURISDICTION; AND
YOU ARE ACCESSING THIS WEBSITE FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY;
YOU WILL NOT TRANSMIT OR OTHERWISE SEND ANY INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS WEBSITE TO ANY PERSONS (I) IN THE UNITED STATES; OR (II) WHO ARE U.S. PERSONS OR (III) IN ANY OTHER RESTRICTED JURISDICTION; AND
YOU HAVE READ, UNDERSTOOD AND AGREE TO THE ABOVE.
If you cannot so represent, warrant and agree, you must click the button labelled ‘I disagree’ or otherwise exit this website. If you believe you are a resident of, and located in, a jurisdiction where viewing is permitted by law, and you can confirm that to us, please contact hello@dowgate.co.uk and +44 (0)20 3416 9143.
